• Anti-Spam Policy
  • Copyright Notice
  • DMCA Compliance
  • Earnings Disclaimer
  • Fair Use Disclaimer
  • FTC Compliance
  • Medical Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Social Media Disclaimer
  • Terms and Conditions
InfluencerWorldDaily.com
  • Home
  • Business
    Financial services are pushing up the revenues of the Southeast Asia 500’s most prominent tech startups

    Financial services are pushing up the revenues of the Southeast Asia 500’s most prominent tech startups

    Thieves accused of 0 million jewelry heist also nabbed Apple AirTags and Samsung electronics, authorities claim

    Thieves accused of $100 million jewelry heist also nabbed Apple AirTags and Samsung electronics, authorities claim

    99 Speed Mart’s Southeast Asia 500 debut is the latest milestone for the company and its founder, a childhood polio survivor

    99 Speed Mart’s Southeast Asia 500 debut is the latest milestone for the company and its founder, a childhood polio survivor

    Greenhouse’s new tool for job candidates borrows a trick from dating apps

    Greenhouse’s new tool for job candidates borrows a trick from dating apps

    SATS is Southeast Asia 500’s biggest climber thanks to air travel resurgence, WFS acquisition

    SATS is Southeast Asia 500’s biggest climber thanks to air travel resurgence, WFS acquisition

    Alex Cooper, Barbara Walters documentaries show struggles for women in media

    Alex Cooper, Barbara Walters documentaries show struggles for women in media

  • Politics
    WATCH: Fox News Pentagon reporter praises Trump admin for NO LEAKS on bombing

    WATCH: Fox News Pentagon reporter praises Trump admin for NO LEAKS on bombing

    Welcome To Wonkette Happy Hour, With This Week’s Cocktail, Toasted Pina Colada!

    Welcome To Wonkette Happy Hour, With This Week’s Cocktail, Toasted Pina Colada!

    BREAKING: DNI Tulsi Gabbard calls out the media for taking her out of context

    BREAKING: DNI Tulsi Gabbard calls out the media for taking her out of context

    What the Media is not Telling You About the Iran-Israel War By Howard Bloom

    What the Media is not Telling You About the Iran-Israel War By Howard Bloom

    The Kids Are Alright Except For The Ones Who Are Not Alright! Tabs, Fri., June 20, 2025

    The Kids Are Alright Except For The Ones Who Are Not Alright! Tabs, Fri., June 20, 2025

    GOOD: White House says FAKE NEWS on Guardian ‘tactical nuke’ report

    GOOD: White House says FAKE NEWS on Guardian ‘tactical nuke’ report

  • Marketing
    Supermetrics acquires real-time CDP Relay42

    Supermetrics acquires real-time CDP Relay42

    CFOs want hard numbers, not brand vibes

    CFOs want hard numbers, not brand vibes

    Homegrown martech tools are making a comeback

    Homegrown martech tools are making a comeback

    It’s time to move on from multi-touch attribution

    It’s time to move on from multi-touch attribution

    Marketing is broken. Privacy can fix it. by Usercentrics

    Marketing is broken. Privacy can fix it. by Usercentrics

    7 vanity metrics marketers should avoid, and 7 to replace them

    7 vanity metrics marketers should avoid, and 7 to replace them

  • CEO
    Sai Meda Enhances Cloud Security and Reduces Vulnerabilities Through Strategic Initiatives

    Sai Meda Enhances Cloud Security and Reduces Vulnerabilities Through Strategic Initiatives

    The Five X-Factors That Distinguish Real Leaders

    The Five X-Factors That Distinguish Real Leaders

    The Leadership Advantage of Having Real-Time Visibility

    The Leadership Advantage of Having Real-Time Visibility

    ‘You Have To Be A Certain Trumpet’

    ‘You Have To Be A Certain Trumpet’

    Why The Best Leaders Must Train Like Elite Athletes

    Why The Best Leaders Must Train Like Elite Athletes

    The Secret To Innovation Is ‘Vertical Innovation’

    The Secret To Innovation Is ‘Vertical Innovation’

  • Fashion
    The Shoe Trend It Girls Are Wearing With Miniskirts in NYC

    The Shoe Trend It Girls Are Wearing With Miniskirts in NYC

    Ruffled Dress Styling Tips For An All-Season Slay

    Ruffled Dress Styling Tips For An All-Season Slay

    7 Summer Fashion Trends That Will Be Everywhere In 2025

    7 Summer Fashion Trends That Will Be Everywhere In 2025

    US billionaire Peter Kern acquires Italian lingerie label La Perla

    US billionaire Peter Kern acquires Italian lingerie label La Perla

    This Is Summer 2025’s Hottest Handbag Color Trend

    This Is Summer 2025’s Hottest Handbag Color Trend

    Tyler Perry Is Facing A 0 Million Lawsuit For Sexual Assault

    Tyler Perry Is Facing A $260 Million Lawsuit For Sexual Assault

  • Music
    Dua Lipa, Surprise Guest Charli XCX Perform ‘360’ in London

    Dua Lipa, Surprise Guest Charli XCX Perform ‘360’ in London

    Machine Gun Kelly says he got Bob Dylan to narrate his album trailer through “pure desperation”

    Machine Gun Kelly says he got Bob Dylan to narrate his album trailer through “pure desperation”

    Polo G Settles Lawsuit Over Canceled European Tour From 2023

    Polo G Settles Lawsuit Over Canceled European Tour From 2023

    Listen to Inhaler’s dreamy cover of Kavinsky’s ‘Night Call’

    Listen to Inhaler’s dreamy cover of Kavinsky’s ‘Night Call’

    Rachel Zegler Sings Iconic ‘Evita’ Song to Crowd Outside Theater

    Rachel Zegler Sings Iconic ‘Evita’ Song to Crowd Outside Theater

    Watch Coldplay play ‘Speed Of Sound’ in full as band for the first time since 2016

    Watch Coldplay play ‘Speed Of Sound’ in full as band for the first time since 2016

  • Film
    Forgotten 1995 Movies That Deserve to Be Rediscovered

    Forgotten 1995 Movies That Deserve to Be Rediscovered

    10 Worst ‘90s TV Villains, Ranked

    10 Worst ‘90s TV Villains, Ranked

    Intro to Our Juneteenth Edition of Black Writers Week 2025 | Black Writers Week

    Intro to Our Juneteenth Edition of Black Writers Week 2025 | Black Writers Week

    Why Batman Is a Huge Problem For the New DC Universe

    Why Batman Is a Huge Problem For the New DC Universe

    John Malkovich, 71, Is Dividing Critics and Audiences on Rotten Tomatoes With His Wild French Comedy

    John Malkovich, 71, Is Dividing Critics and Audiences on Rotten Tomatoes With His Wild French Comedy

    Happy Heavenly Birthday, Roger Ebert: June 18, 1942 – April 4, 2013 | Tributes

    Happy Heavenly Birthday, Roger Ebert: June 18, 1942 – April 4, 2013 | Tributes

  • Television
    Power Book IV: Force: Season Three; Starz Unveils Teaser and Photos for Final Season – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Power Book IV: Force: Season Three; Starz Unveils Teaser and Photos for Final Season – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Wednesday TV Ratings: MasterChef, Children Ruin Everything, Raid the Cage, Chicago Med, Shark Tank – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Wednesday TV Ratings: MasterChef, Children Ruin Everything, Raid the Cage, Chicago Med, Shark Tank – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Children Ruin Everything: Season Four Ratings + Viewer Votes – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Children Ruin Everything: Season Four Ratings + Viewer Votes – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Shiny Happy People: Season Two Renewal and Premiere Date Announced for Prime Video Docuseries – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Shiny Happy People: Season Two Renewal and Premiere Date Announced for Prime Video Docuseries – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Night Court: Melissa Rauch Talks NBC Sitcom Cancellation and Efforts to Save It – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Night Court: Melissa Rauch Talks NBC Sitcom Cancellation and Efforts to Save It – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Welcome to Plathville: Season Seven; TLC Previews Return of Family Reality Series – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Welcome to Plathville: Season Seven; TLC Previews Return of Family Reality Series – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

  • Books
    Everything Changes: Young Adult Books That Hit Hard

    Everything Changes: Young Adult Books That Hit Hard

    A BROKEN WINDOW | Kirkus Reviews

    A BROKEN WINDOW | Kirkus Reviews

    Book Riot’s Deals of the Day for June 20, 2025

    Book Riot’s Deals of the Day for June 20, 2025

    Think Like a Founder: Books for Big Business Moves

    Think Like a Founder: Books for Big Business Moves

    WEEPERS | Kirkus Reviews

    WEEPERS | Kirkus Reviews

    BookCon Is Back in 2026

    BookCon Is Back in 2026

  • Social Media
    Social Platforms Explore Age Verification Options to Comply With Teen Access Regulations

    Social Platforms Explore Age Verification Options to Comply With Teen Access Regulations

    How Emotional Eating Disrupts Weight Loss—and What You Can Do About ItTrimBody M.D. Explores the Science Behind Stress Cravings and Practical Steps Toward Healthier Habits

    Meta Announces Oakley-Branded AI Glasses Aimed at Athletes

    Meta Announces Oakley-Branded AI Glasses Aimed at Athletes

    Using a Secured Credit Card to Build Your Credit History

    LinkedIn Video Strategy: Becoming a Respected Industry Leader

    LinkedIn Video Strategy: Becoming a Respected Industry Leader

    Meta Gains New Ad Safety Certifications for Facebook and Instagram

    Meta Gains New Ad Safety Certifications for Facebook and Instagram

  • Cover Story
  • Contact
    • About
  • Home
  • Business
    Financial services are pushing up the revenues of the Southeast Asia 500’s most prominent tech startups

    Financial services are pushing up the revenues of the Southeast Asia 500’s most prominent tech startups

    Thieves accused of 0 million jewelry heist also nabbed Apple AirTags and Samsung electronics, authorities claim

    Thieves accused of $100 million jewelry heist also nabbed Apple AirTags and Samsung electronics, authorities claim

    99 Speed Mart’s Southeast Asia 500 debut is the latest milestone for the company and its founder, a childhood polio survivor

    99 Speed Mart’s Southeast Asia 500 debut is the latest milestone for the company and its founder, a childhood polio survivor

    Greenhouse’s new tool for job candidates borrows a trick from dating apps

    Greenhouse’s new tool for job candidates borrows a trick from dating apps

    SATS is Southeast Asia 500’s biggest climber thanks to air travel resurgence, WFS acquisition

    SATS is Southeast Asia 500’s biggest climber thanks to air travel resurgence, WFS acquisition

    Alex Cooper, Barbara Walters documentaries show struggles for women in media

    Alex Cooper, Barbara Walters documentaries show struggles for women in media

  • Politics
    WATCH: Fox News Pentagon reporter praises Trump admin for NO LEAKS on bombing

    WATCH: Fox News Pentagon reporter praises Trump admin for NO LEAKS on bombing

    Welcome To Wonkette Happy Hour, With This Week’s Cocktail, Toasted Pina Colada!

    Welcome To Wonkette Happy Hour, With This Week’s Cocktail, Toasted Pina Colada!

    BREAKING: DNI Tulsi Gabbard calls out the media for taking her out of context

    BREAKING: DNI Tulsi Gabbard calls out the media for taking her out of context

    What the Media is not Telling You About the Iran-Israel War By Howard Bloom

    What the Media is not Telling You About the Iran-Israel War By Howard Bloom

    The Kids Are Alright Except For The Ones Who Are Not Alright! Tabs, Fri., June 20, 2025

    The Kids Are Alright Except For The Ones Who Are Not Alright! Tabs, Fri., June 20, 2025

    GOOD: White House says FAKE NEWS on Guardian ‘tactical nuke’ report

    GOOD: White House says FAKE NEWS on Guardian ‘tactical nuke’ report

  • Marketing
    Supermetrics acquires real-time CDP Relay42

    Supermetrics acquires real-time CDP Relay42

    CFOs want hard numbers, not brand vibes

    CFOs want hard numbers, not brand vibes

    Homegrown martech tools are making a comeback

    Homegrown martech tools are making a comeback

    It’s time to move on from multi-touch attribution

    It’s time to move on from multi-touch attribution

    Marketing is broken. Privacy can fix it. by Usercentrics

    Marketing is broken. Privacy can fix it. by Usercentrics

    7 vanity metrics marketers should avoid, and 7 to replace them

    7 vanity metrics marketers should avoid, and 7 to replace them

  • CEO
    Sai Meda Enhances Cloud Security and Reduces Vulnerabilities Through Strategic Initiatives

    Sai Meda Enhances Cloud Security and Reduces Vulnerabilities Through Strategic Initiatives

    The Five X-Factors That Distinguish Real Leaders

    The Five X-Factors That Distinguish Real Leaders

    The Leadership Advantage of Having Real-Time Visibility

    The Leadership Advantage of Having Real-Time Visibility

    ‘You Have To Be A Certain Trumpet’

    ‘You Have To Be A Certain Trumpet’

    Why The Best Leaders Must Train Like Elite Athletes

    Why The Best Leaders Must Train Like Elite Athletes

    The Secret To Innovation Is ‘Vertical Innovation’

    The Secret To Innovation Is ‘Vertical Innovation’

  • Fashion
    The Shoe Trend It Girls Are Wearing With Miniskirts in NYC

    The Shoe Trend It Girls Are Wearing With Miniskirts in NYC

    Ruffled Dress Styling Tips For An All-Season Slay

    Ruffled Dress Styling Tips For An All-Season Slay

    7 Summer Fashion Trends That Will Be Everywhere In 2025

    7 Summer Fashion Trends That Will Be Everywhere In 2025

    US billionaire Peter Kern acquires Italian lingerie label La Perla

    US billionaire Peter Kern acquires Italian lingerie label La Perla

    This Is Summer 2025’s Hottest Handbag Color Trend

    This Is Summer 2025’s Hottest Handbag Color Trend

    Tyler Perry Is Facing A 0 Million Lawsuit For Sexual Assault

    Tyler Perry Is Facing A $260 Million Lawsuit For Sexual Assault

  • Music
    Dua Lipa, Surprise Guest Charli XCX Perform ‘360’ in London

    Dua Lipa, Surprise Guest Charli XCX Perform ‘360’ in London

    Machine Gun Kelly says he got Bob Dylan to narrate his album trailer through “pure desperation”

    Machine Gun Kelly says he got Bob Dylan to narrate his album trailer through “pure desperation”

    Polo G Settles Lawsuit Over Canceled European Tour From 2023

    Polo G Settles Lawsuit Over Canceled European Tour From 2023

    Listen to Inhaler’s dreamy cover of Kavinsky’s ‘Night Call’

    Listen to Inhaler’s dreamy cover of Kavinsky’s ‘Night Call’

    Rachel Zegler Sings Iconic ‘Evita’ Song to Crowd Outside Theater

    Rachel Zegler Sings Iconic ‘Evita’ Song to Crowd Outside Theater

    Watch Coldplay play ‘Speed Of Sound’ in full as band for the first time since 2016

    Watch Coldplay play ‘Speed Of Sound’ in full as band for the first time since 2016

  • Film
    Forgotten 1995 Movies That Deserve to Be Rediscovered

    Forgotten 1995 Movies That Deserve to Be Rediscovered

    10 Worst ‘90s TV Villains, Ranked

    10 Worst ‘90s TV Villains, Ranked

    Intro to Our Juneteenth Edition of Black Writers Week 2025 | Black Writers Week

    Intro to Our Juneteenth Edition of Black Writers Week 2025 | Black Writers Week

    Why Batman Is a Huge Problem For the New DC Universe

    Why Batman Is a Huge Problem For the New DC Universe

    John Malkovich, 71, Is Dividing Critics and Audiences on Rotten Tomatoes With His Wild French Comedy

    John Malkovich, 71, Is Dividing Critics and Audiences on Rotten Tomatoes With His Wild French Comedy

    Happy Heavenly Birthday, Roger Ebert: June 18, 1942 – April 4, 2013 | Tributes

    Happy Heavenly Birthday, Roger Ebert: June 18, 1942 – April 4, 2013 | Tributes

  • Television
    Power Book IV: Force: Season Three; Starz Unveils Teaser and Photos for Final Season – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Power Book IV: Force: Season Three; Starz Unveils Teaser and Photos for Final Season – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Wednesday TV Ratings: MasterChef, Children Ruin Everything, Raid the Cage, Chicago Med, Shark Tank – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Wednesday TV Ratings: MasterChef, Children Ruin Everything, Raid the Cage, Chicago Med, Shark Tank – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Children Ruin Everything: Season Four Ratings + Viewer Votes – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Children Ruin Everything: Season Four Ratings + Viewer Votes – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Shiny Happy People: Season Two Renewal and Premiere Date Announced for Prime Video Docuseries – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Shiny Happy People: Season Two Renewal and Premiere Date Announced for Prime Video Docuseries – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Night Court: Melissa Rauch Talks NBC Sitcom Cancellation and Efforts to Save It – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Night Court: Melissa Rauch Talks NBC Sitcom Cancellation and Efforts to Save It – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Welcome to Plathville: Season Seven; TLC Previews Return of Family Reality Series – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

    Welcome to Plathville: Season Seven; TLC Previews Return of Family Reality Series – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

  • Books
    Everything Changes: Young Adult Books That Hit Hard

    Everything Changes: Young Adult Books That Hit Hard

    A BROKEN WINDOW | Kirkus Reviews

    A BROKEN WINDOW | Kirkus Reviews

    Book Riot’s Deals of the Day for June 20, 2025

    Book Riot’s Deals of the Day for June 20, 2025

    Think Like a Founder: Books for Big Business Moves

    Think Like a Founder: Books for Big Business Moves

    WEEPERS | Kirkus Reviews

    WEEPERS | Kirkus Reviews

    BookCon Is Back in 2026

    BookCon Is Back in 2026

  • Social Media
    Social Platforms Explore Age Verification Options to Comply With Teen Access Regulations

    Social Platforms Explore Age Verification Options to Comply With Teen Access Regulations

    How Emotional Eating Disrupts Weight Loss—and What You Can Do About ItTrimBody M.D. Explores the Science Behind Stress Cravings and Practical Steps Toward Healthier Habits

    Meta Announces Oakley-Branded AI Glasses Aimed at Athletes

    Meta Announces Oakley-Branded AI Glasses Aimed at Athletes

    Using a Secured Credit Card to Build Your Credit History

    LinkedIn Video Strategy: Becoming a Respected Industry Leader

    LinkedIn Video Strategy: Becoming a Respected Industry Leader

    Meta Gains New Ad Safety Certifications for Facebook and Instagram

    Meta Gains New Ad Safety Certifications for Facebook and Instagram

  • Cover Story
  • Contact
    • About
No Result
View All Result
InfluencerWorldDaily.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Books

Why Do Reviewers Include Disclaimers About ARCs?

by Admin
June 20, 2022
in Books
Why Do Reviewers Include Disclaimers About ARCs?



Why Do Reviewers Include Disclaimers About ARCs?

ARCs (advanced reader copies), also known as galleys, e-galleys and DRCs (digital review copies) are a staple of the bookish world. They’re versions of books that publishers (and sometimes authors) give to reviewers, critics, booksellers, librarians, and other book-related media people before the book is actually published. If you’ve ever wondered how a review can drop on publication day, or why people are raving about a book months before its publication date — ARCs are your answer.

Book professionals often receive ARCs unsolicited from publishers hoping they’ll review them. It’s also a common practice for reviewers and journalists to reach out to publishers to request ARCs of books they’re hoping to read and review. But you don’t have to be a professional book person to read ARCs. Anyone can create an account on NetGalley or Edelweiss, two platforms with huge catalogues of digital ARCs. If you talk about books on social media, have a BookTok account, write a blog, or actively review on Goodreads — there’s nothing stopping you from requesting early copies.

But what happens after you’ve read that ARC and are sitting down to write your review? Do you have to disclose that you received an ARC? Does it matter if you do? Let’s get into it.

Are reviewers legally required to disclose?

The short answer is no. The longer answer is sometimes. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) issues guidelines about reviews, endorsements, and testimonials of products and services. The guidelines essentially exist to ensure that someone reading a rave review of a new vacuum cleaner knows if that reviewer has been paid by the vacuum cleaner company to write the review.

In 2010, the FTC updated the guidelines to specifically address bloggers, social media influencers, and other people who review via word of mouth. Here’s what the FTC said in their press release (from 2009):

“The revised Guides specify that while decisions will be reached on a case-by-case basis, the post of a blogger who receives cash or in-kind payment to review a product is considered an endorsement. Thus, bloggers who make an endorsement must disclose the material connections they share with the seller of the product or service.”

Book Deals Newsletter

Sign up for our Book Deals newsletter and get up to 80% off books you actually want to read.

Thank you for signing up! Keep an eye on your inbox.

By signing up you agree to our terms of use

This is pretty straightforward: if you’re paid to review a book, or if you receive a free copy of a book with the explicit understanding that you will review it, you’re required to disclose. Back in 2010, a lot of bloggers interpreted this to mean that they would now be legally required to disclose every time they read and reviewed an ARC. I am honestly still baffled by this, because it is extremely rare that reviewers receive review copies in exchange for anything. Receiving a “cash or in-kind payment to review a product” is not common in the book world. Most of us get review copies with the understanding that we might write a review.

I’m not going to wade into the legalese, but the takeaway is that ARCs are not in-kind payments. There are a few obvious exceptions. If you’re paid by a publisher to write a review, you are legally required to disclose that they paid you, whether your review is positive or negative. This is also true for affiliate links: if you might receive money when someone buys a book by clicking on a link, you’re required to disclose. This article from the Independent Book Publishers Association does a great job of breaking it down.

So, why do so many reviewers disclose that they’ve received ARCs? To find out, I polled 20 Rioters and Bookstagramers. 35% of those I surveyed reported they disclose. 55% reported they disclose sometimes, depending on the context, and 10% said they do not disclose. Reasons varied from person to person.

Why Reviewers Disclose

I was surprised by the diversity of reasons reviewers have for disclosing. In general, the respondents who do disclose mentioned doing so for transparency and honesty. A few reviewers mentioned that it’s a way to help people from outside the book world learn about how the book world works. It can be disorienting, if you don’t understand the system, to scroll through Goodreads and see tons of reviews of a book that hasn’t been published yet. Mentioning ARCs explains this phenomenon.

For a lot of reviewers, it depends on context. One person pointed out that they disclose they read an ARC if they’re reviewing the book before publication day, but not afterward. Another reviewer makes a practice to always disclose if they received a finished copy from the publisher.

Rioter and author Susie Dumond makes this excellent point, something I’d never thought of:

“A fair amount of people review books on Goodreads before the book comes out, either with enthusiasm about the concept/cover/marketing copy or to bash or 1 star a book before it’s even available. I want to be clear that I’m leaving a review after reading the book, since that’s not always clear if it’s pre-publication. I know as a reader, before I started writing about books and had access to ARCs, I didn’t understand how Goodreads reviewers could review books before they were out.”

Why Reviewers Don’t Disclose

I personally rarely disclose because it just doesn’t seem that interesting or important. This sentiment was echoed by many of the reviewers I polled — ARCs are a tool, and receiving them does not affect our reviews in any way.

I was intrigued by this insight from Rioter Jeffrey Davies:

“I’m sure we’re all inclined to say we got a free review copy as a form of ‘hey look at me’ that exists across social media regardless of one’s intentions.”

I’d never thought about this, but it’s a good point. Disclosing that you received an ARC can be a form of signaling that you have a certain “status” in the book world. I won’t deny that it’s pretty fun when free books arrive on my doorstep. But there’s nothing special about it. ARCs are a part of the industry. I’m not sure what anyone gains by me announcing that yes, in fact, I receive the tools I need to do my job.

Rioter Annika Barranti Klein makes this excellent and relatable point: “I rarely disclose because I genuinely don’t remember which books I get as ARCs.” She is very good at bringing the humor, but this sentiment speaks to the fact that when you write about books for a living (or even if you’re just an avid reader and reviewer) ARCs are ubiquitous. They’re part of the landscape. The blend into all the other books on your shelf or your Kindle.

“I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.”

I see this sentence a lot on Goodreads especially, and it’s what inspired me to write and research this piece. It baffles me that this particular phrasing is so common! As I mentioned when discussing the FTC guidelines, there are very few instances in which a sentence like this is actually true. Let’s break it down.

The phrase here, the one that makes no sense to me, is in exchange for. I read a lot of ARCs. Sometimes I download them from Edelweiss or NetGalley. Sometimes they arrive unsolicited on my doorstep. Sometimes, when I’m excited about a book, I reach out to a publisher directly and ask for a galley. Never in my life have I been given an ARC in exchange for an honest review. I’m given ARCs in exchange for the possibility of a review. I haven’t signed a contract or made any promises. I’m under no obligation whatsoever to review every ARC I receive. I receive considerably fewer ARCs than other book professionals I know, and I still could never read them all if I tried. I just don’t have the time.

I’m not saying I view ARCs as a perpetual source of free books. They exist for a purpose. Early buzz helps publishers sell copies. Access to ARCS allows writers like me to make lists of books you definitely want to check out this fall — I’m confident about those lists because I’ve been able to read a lot of those books. They’re an integral part of what makes the book world go. I don’t treat ARCs as some kind of never-ending library for my own personal pleasure. I treat them as what they are: a tool I need to do my job.

I know this is small in the scheme of things. But this sentence, this idea that people receive ARCs in exchange for reviews, gives readers, and people new to the book world, the wrong idea. It portrays the relationship between publishers and reviewers to be something other than what it is. Unless I’m paid to write a review, I have no formal relationship with publishers. I am my own person. I read books that interest me. I read upcoming books that interest me so that I can help get them into the hands of readers who will also love them.

Publishers make early copies of books available, which makes early reviews possible, which hopefully generates some buzz and encourages people to buy books. That’s it. It’s not an exchange. It’s just how publishing works.

What about paid reviews?

Paid reviews are a different beast. I do want to point out that publications that publish sponsored content make it clear up front that they’ve been paid (and if they don’t, they should). Being paid to write a review is a situation in which an exchange occurs: you’re given money (and presumably the book) in exchange for a review.

But what about writers like me, who are paid by publications like Book Riot? As long as I’m not being paid by the publisher, I don’t consider writing like this an exchange. Several of the reviewers I polled came to the same conclusion. Rioter Trizah Price pointed out that she doesn’t disclose she receives ARCs in her work writing and podcasting for Book Riot because it’s implied. Have you ever seen a disclaimer at the bottom of a a review in The New York Times stating that the reviewer received an ARC? No.

Other Ways of Disclosing

I’d love to see the “I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review” sentence disappear forever, though I doubt I will. But there are lots of other ways reviewers disclose that strike me as a lot more accurate — and useful to readers and publishers alike.

About 60% of the reviewers I polled who do disclose they get ARCs reported they use some version of this phrase: “Thanks to the publisher for the gifted copy.” This is my personal favorite way to disclose. I like that it names ARCs for what they are: a kind of gift, with no obligations or expectations attached. I also like the expression of gratitude. I love getting to read early copies of books because my favorite thing in the world is championing books I adore. One of the best ways to do that is to talk them up before publication.

Another common version of this to tag publishers on social media. On Bookstagram, it’s common to see reviewers tag publishers and add a comment like, “thanks to the tagged publishers for the gifted copies.” About 40% of people who said they disclose ARCs use this strategy. This makes sense to me because it’s a bit of a good-faith gesture. A publisher sent you a book, hoping you’d review it. Tagging them is a way to let them know that you have; they can take it or leave it. One person I polled summed it up nicely: “For me, mentioning that I got a book from the publisher and tagging them feels like fulfilling my half of the deal.”

I read a lot of books from small indie presses. It takes a fair bit money and time to produce ARCs, and I am genuinely grateful that publishers do it. When I read a book from an indie press and love it, I almost always tag the publisher if I post about it, not just as a way of saying thank you, but as a way to potentially boost my review’s reach, and get that book into the hands of more readers — which is always my goal when I fall in love with a book.

Another popular way to disclose is simply: “I received a free copy of this book.” I like this better than the “in exchange for” sentence. But do I also need to mention that I read a book via the library? That I borrowed it from a friend? That my dad gave it to me for my birthday? One respondent pointed out that, in some ways, receiving an ARC is no different from checking a book out of the library. Sure, it’s a little more complicated than that, but think about it for a minute: are you more inclined to give a library book a positive review because you got it for free? I doubt it. For every reviewer that I polled or have spoken with, even the ones who do disclose, ARCs are the same.

Rioter Margaret Kingsbury uses this phrase: “The publisher sent me this book for review consideration but all opinions are my own.” While I personally feel no need to disclose, I love this because it so accurately describes exactly what happened. This reader was sent a book for review consideration, decided to read it, and has now written a review containing her honest opinions.

Is Disclosing Important?

It depends who you ask. Among the reviewers I polled, the response was mixed, though leaned toward disclosure not being that important. Four respondents expressed some version of: yes, it’s important and people should disclose. Twelve respondents expressed some version of: it doesn’t matter much. A few people mentioned that it depends on the context.

It became abundantly clear, while I was working on this piece, that all reviewers approach this issue differently. People choose to disclose or not for different reasons. What this means for those reading reviews is that, while seeing an ARC disclosure might tell you something, it doesn’t tell you much. Read the review. Read other reviews. Follow people on social media whose opinions speak to you. Read media websites that consistently publish reviews that you find thoughtful, challenging, enjoyable. Judge the work.

Does Seeing ARC Disclosures Change How You Read a Review?

The majority of respondents agreed that seeing an ARC disclosure doesn’t change how they read reviews.

Susie Dumond noted: “It doesn’t really change my opinion of the review, although sometimes it’s a sign to me that the reviewer is someone involved in the book world in some capacity and therefore is likely a frequent reader and reviewer.”

This struck me as a good point — a review disclosure often tells you more about the reviewer and their role in the book world than it does about the review itself.

Someone else mentioned that seeing a disclosure sometimes makes them more skeptical of gushing reviews. This brings up another layer of complexity. I rarely review books I don’t love. I’m not a critic. Sometimes I mention something that didn’t work for me, and every now and then, if I feel strongly about a book I didn’t like, I write about it. But generally I’m jumping up and down about books. Is this one of the reasons I don’t generally disclose? Is there a chance that, while the idea behind disclosing is honesty, people will think I’m dishonest because I only write positive reviews? Another respondent mentioned that they don’t think disclosing is important unless the review is very positive or very negative. There’s a lot to ponder.

The Book World vs. Everyone Else

I couldn’t agree more with this observation from Rioter Jamie Canavés: “Anyone who knows anything about the industry is aware that reviewers get galleys (same as when you read a review for a film that hasn’t come out yet you know they had early access). I guess the disclosure is only for people who would never have thought about this or don’t know how it works.”

This got me thinking about the book industry more broadly. Why is the onus on reviewers to disclose? Books, it seems, are one of the few forms of art/media where this is the expectation. Granted, I don’t have any data to back this up. But when you read a review of a movie, do you look for a disclosure saying the reviewer saw an early screening? What about plays? Isn’t this what previews are — a series of performances before the official opening night, to which a theatre invites all the critics? Are theatre critics expected to disclose they went to a preview? They literally cannot review the show without seeing it. Who cares if they paid for a ticket or not.

Another respondent wrote: “I think it’s useful for people to know generally that most early reviews come courtesy of publisher provided copies but this really matters most when a book is newly released. Once a book has been out in the world does it matter if you bought it or checked it out from the library or borrowed from a friend? Book reviews fall in a different category to me than reviews of most goods or services. Paying for a book does not make you more or less likely to post a positive review, IMO.”

What I’d like, rather than scrolling through disclosure after disclosure in every review I read, is more transparency about how the publishing industry works. Readers have a right to know that early reviewers receive galleys. Despite being an avid reader all my life, I didn’t know what an ARC was until I started writing about books professionally. It’s not a big secret, and we shouldn’t treat it like one.

In Conclusion

I love books. I love reading books and I love writing about books and I love recommending books. That’s why we’re all here, right? I’m also fascinated by the inner workings of industries I’m involved with and/or care about. But the bottom line is that there is no right answer regarding disclosing ARCs. There are reasons to disclose and reasons not to disclose, contexts where it matters more and contexts where it matters less. Do what works for you. Follow reviewers whose work you love. And then get back to reading.


Related Reading:

How to Get Audiobook ARCs

What To Do with the ARCs You Want to Unhaul



Original Source Link

Admin

Admin

Related Posts

Everything Changes: Young Adult Books That Hit Hard
Books

Everything Changes: Young Adult Books That Hit Hard

June 22, 2025
A BROKEN WINDOW | Kirkus Reviews
Books

A BROKEN WINDOW | Kirkus Reviews

June 21, 2025
Book Riot’s Deals of the Day for June 20, 2025
Books

Book Riot’s Deals of the Day for June 20, 2025

June 21, 2025
Next Post
Mike Lee Wishes Somebody Would Think Of The Poor Lonely Guns :(

Mike Lee Wishes Somebody Would Think Of The Poor Lonely Guns :(

Yellen urges less dependence on other nations for key supplies, urges ‘friendly shoring’

Yellen urges less dependence on other nations for key supplies, urges 'friendly shoring'

7 Dance Artists on Drake’s ‘Honestly, Nevermind’ You Need To Know – Billboard

7 Dance Artists on Drake’s ‘Honestly, Nevermind’ You Need To Know – Billboard

Latest Posts

Power Book IV: Force: Season Three; Starz Unveils Teaser and Photos for Final Season – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

Power Book IV: Force: Season Three; Starz Unveils Teaser and Photos for Final Season – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

6 hours ago
Supermetrics acquires real-time CDP Relay42

Supermetrics acquires real-time CDP Relay42

6 hours ago
Sai Meda Enhances Cloud Security and Reduces Vulnerabilities Through Strategic Initiatives

Sai Meda Enhances Cloud Security and Reduces Vulnerabilities Through Strategic Initiatives

6 hours ago
The Shoe Trend It Girls Are Wearing With Miniskirts in NYC

The Shoe Trend It Girls Are Wearing With Miniskirts in NYC

6 hours ago
Social Platforms Explore Age Verification Options to Comply With Teen Access Regulations

Social Platforms Explore Age Verification Options to Comply With Teen Access Regulations

6 hours ago
Dua Lipa, Surprise Guest Charli XCX Perform ‘360’ in London

Dua Lipa, Surprise Guest Charli XCX Perform ‘360’ in London

7 hours ago
Financial services are pushing up the revenues of the Southeast Asia 500’s most prominent tech startups

Financial services are pushing up the revenues of the Southeast Asia 500’s most prominent tech startups

7 hours ago
WATCH: Fox News Pentagon reporter praises Trump admin for NO LEAKS on bombing

WATCH: Fox News Pentagon reporter praises Trump admin for NO LEAKS on bombing

7 hours ago
Everything Changes: Young Adult Books That Hit Hard

Everything Changes: Young Adult Books That Hit Hard

7 hours ago
Forgotten 1995 Movies That Deserve to Be Rediscovered

Forgotten 1995 Movies That Deserve to Be Rediscovered

8 hours ago

Categories

  • Books (4,524)
  • Business (5,096)
  • CEO (4,006)
  • Cover Story (1)
  • Events (9)
  • Fashion (4,788)
  • Film (5,059)
  • Interviews (44)
  • Marketing (3,507)
  • Music (5,112)
  • News (75)
  • Politics (4,026)
  • Social Media (3,832)
  • Television (5,093)
  • Uncategorized (1)
No Result
View All Result
get paid to do simple media jobs online

Editor's Picks

Think Like a Founder: Books for Big Business Moves

Polo G Settles Lawsuit Over Canceled European Tour From 2023

WEEPERS | Kirkus Reviews

Hotel Costiera: Prime Video Releases Trailer and Premiere Date for Action-Drama Starring Jesse Williams – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

The Madame Blanc Mysteries: Season Four Trailer and Poster Released by Acorn TV – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

Say Hello to the New Duchess of Tintagel

Archives

  • June 2025
  • May 2025
  • April 2025
  • March 2025
  • February 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • June 2024
  • May 2024
  • April 2024
  • March 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022

Trending

Why the CHRO of IBM says she always asks new hires to talk about a time they’ve failed
Business

Why the CHRO of IBM says she always asks new hires to talk about a time they’ve failed

by Admin
June 17, 2025

People have a natural fear of showing weakness, especially during job interviews when they’re trying to present...

The Kids Are Alright Except For The Ones Who Are Not Alright! Tabs, Fri., June 20, 2025

The Kids Are Alright Except For The Ones Who Are Not Alright! Tabs, Fri., June 20, 2025

June 20, 2025
Homegrown martech tools are making a comeback

Homegrown martech tools are making a comeback

June 21, 2025
Greenhouse’s new tool for job candidates borrows a trick from dating apps

Greenhouse’s new tool for job candidates borrows a trick from dating apps

June 20, 2025
US billionaire Peter Kern acquires Italian lingerie label La Perla

US billionaire Peter Kern acquires Italian lingerie label La Perla

June 20, 2025

Editors Picks

Fair Play movie review & film summary (2022)

Fair Play movie review & film summary (2022)

July 9, 2022
Ex-soldier Kindly Myers shows off her Corvette, gushes about how much she loves that car

Ex-soldier Kindly Myers shows off her Corvette, gushes about how much she loves that car

December 22, 2022
Kelley Flanagan shows some leg on vacation in Capri

Kelley Flanagan shows some leg on vacation in Capri

July 25, 2022

Category

  • Books (4,524)
  • Business (5,096)
  • CEO (4,006)
  • Cover Story (1)
  • Events (9)
  • Fashion (4,788)
  • Film (5,059)
  • Interviews (44)
  • Marketing (3,507)
  • Music (5,112)
  • News (75)
  • Politics (4,026)
  • Social Media (3,832)
  • Television (5,093)
  • Uncategorized (1)

Readers Picks

Power Book IV: Force: Season Three; Starz Unveils Teaser and Photos for Final Season – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

Power Book IV: Force: Season Three; Starz Unveils Teaser and Photos for Final Season – canceled + renewed TV shows, ratings

June 22, 2025
Supermetrics acquires real-time CDP Relay42

Supermetrics acquires real-time CDP Relay42

June 22, 2025
Sai Meda Enhances Cloud Security and Reduces Vulnerabilities Through Strategic Initiatives

Sai Meda Enhances Cloud Security and Reduces Vulnerabilities Through Strategic Initiatives

June 22, 2025

© 2022 Copyright - InfluencerWorldDaily.com - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Marketing
  • CEO
  • Fashion
  • Music
  • Film
  • Television
  • Books
  • Social Media
  • Cover Story
  • Contact
    • About

© 2022 Copyright - InfluencerWorldDaily.com - All Rights Reserved

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
Cookie SettingsAccept All
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
CookieDurationDescription
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
SAVE & ACCEPT